Good On You alternatives need to make the clothing question clear. A brand’s labour policies and the composition of one shirt are different parts of the decision.
A high brand rating does not automatically mean a garment meets my plant fibre preference. A natural fibre declaration does not establish fair wages or the whole environmental impact either.
This comparison separates brand level assessments from product level composition records. The relevant sources are the published method, the garment declaration and the evidence supporting each wider claim.
Our own clothing results can have incomplete catalogue coverage. I keep that limitation attached to the score rather than presenting a partial record as a complete brand audit.
Choose the information you need, then follow the exact item and the dated report. That is more useful than looking for one universal ethical label.
Good On You is measuring something different
Good On You cofounder Gordon Renouf has explained that fashion information is often less accessible than food certification data. That is precisely why a brand level assessment matters. It can shine a light on labour, animals and environmental policy where the shirt label tells you nothing.
But a company rating cannot tell you whether the specific jumper in your hand is 100% cotton, 70% cotton or 100% polyester. Under our natural fibre composition threshold those three are not the same. I don’t soften the distinction because the brand is fashionable or because I like the owner.
For me the proper comparison is a garment tag alongside the brand’s sourced record. No anonymous allegations. No assuming a fibre blend demonstrates exploitation. And no pretending that a genuinely natural fabric automatically proves fair wages.
Read Renouf’s published interview and Good On You’s explanation of why its ratings use public evidence.
The part of a garment a brand score will never show
Good On You examines a company’s disclosed practices across people, planet and animals. Those assessments can reveal things a fibre label does not say.
A factory audit, supplier disclosure, wage policy and animal sourcing position are serious matters. I wouldn’t replace that work with a simple natural fibre check.
But the reverse is equally important. A brand can communicate a sophisticated environmental policy while the garment in your hand contains polyester or elastane.
Under our composition preference, a mixed synthetic and natural fabric does not reach the top natural fibre threshold. The company might still do some things better than a brand selling pure cotton.
That is why I refuse to average every moral and material question into one unexplained number.
Good On You’s cofounders have spoken about the lack of accessible information in the fashion industry. That is a legitimate reason for a ratings service.
The reader still needs to look at the specific product rather than assume the corporate result covers every collection or factory.
The hardest part is accepting contradiction. A garment from a high rated brand can fail my material standard.
A beautifully made natural shirt can come from a company whose supplier information is absent. I want both facts visible.
I don’t want either one hidden to give the shopper a tidy conclusion.
Repair can change the answer without changing the score
A used jacket with a broken zip could be repaired for years of wear. Buying an entirely new, sustainably marketed coat because a score told you to shop again might be the poorer decision.
The useful question is what the repair costs locally and how long the garment will be worn afterwards.
Check whether the maker supplies care instructions, spare hardware or fabric for a repair. Check whether the garment’s seams allow alteration and whether cleaning instructions are reasonable for everyday life.
Those details affect the material life of the item, even if they aren’t included in the brand’s reputation rating.
I have friends who own clothing brands. Applying our fibre criteria can be uncomfortable when one of their garments falls short.
That shouldn’t change the material declaration. What can change is the record when a formula, collection or source was documented incorrectly.
This isn’t personal. It is what a standard is for.
What Vivi’s swimwear taught me about a brand score
While interviewing Vivi Rufino of Freedom Ecowear, I asked about the stretch in her swimwear. She explained why natural fibres need some help retaining their fit when wet. We discussed two declared blends, one with 3% Lycra and another with 8%. Those were specific designs she showed me, not a claim about every garment she sells.
Under a strict 100% natural-fibre preference, neither blend earns full purity points. That doesn’t erase the questions she answered about her materials and workshop. My conversation with Vivi about spandex and her workshop in the Dominican bush show why a brand-level rating and a garment composition are separate pieces of research.
That is what I want a reader to bring to My Ideal World. Look at the exact fabric. Then look at the people and practices. Do not let one number pretend to explain the entire company.
Our clothing score is about the fibre, not the marketing
Under Throne Standard 2.2 and textile baseline 1.3.3, the clothing metric is the average declared plant-fibre percentage of products with complete, attributable compositions. Unknown products lower disclosure coverage and remain outside the value calculation. The present 5/5 band requires 100% under that defined metric.
What we will not score as if it were composition. We do not score fashion popularity, a founder’s personality, app downloads or ethical virtue from fibre composition. Polyester content is not proof of unsafe wear, and missing fibre declarations do not automatically score 1/5. Labour and animal welfare belong in separate evidence assessments.
Read the standard version named in the individual report, together with its metric, evidence dates, eligible products and coverage. Category specific methods can answer different questions, and the live report may use a later version than an older explanatory page.
A missing or conflicting declaration is unresolved, not proof of a bad composition. Read the exact standard; challenge an incorrect record.
What the comparison actually shows
These are different kinds of evidence. Before choosing an app, distinguish a label-derived ingredient, a scoring rule, a measured quantity and a brand policy. The table names the limits rather than declaring an unsupported winner.
| Question | First tool or evidence | Important limit |
|---|---|---|
| Good On You | Brand practices under people, planet and animals | Not a garment-level laboratory assay |
| Resale marketplace | Second-hand availability and reuse | Does not establish original factory conditions |
| Repair directory | Keeping an existing item useful | May not assess supply-chain ethics |
| My Ideal World | Composition and research on brands and materials | Coverage must be shown for exact items |
What My Ideal World actually scores on clothing
Our score is a test against the Throne Standard, not a prize for whichever app has the most downloads. The relevant published standard is versioned, and category results must keep their own meaning.
An ingredient preference, laboratory result, animal-welfare policy and nutritional profile are not interchangeable evidence.
Picture receives a provisional 1/5 in the live Throne Standard 3.0.0 report checked on 17 November 2026. It has 971 complete declarations from 1,116 eligible products, with 39 missing declarations and 106 technical gaps. Its verified plant evidence is 37.18%, with 87.01% coverage.
Verified plant-evidence credit is 37.18%. This is an evidence-limited result, not a claim that every garment is synthetic or unsafe. Read Picture’s current breakdown.
Gray Label receives a provisional 3/5 in the live report checked on 17 November 2026. It has 305 complete declarations from 394 eligible products, no missing declarations and 89 technical gaps. Verified plant evidence is 85.67%, with 77.41% coverage. The report identifies incomplete coverage rather than a final whole brand assessment. Read Gray Label’s current breakdown
| Brand | HTT score | Composition evidence | Assessment limit |
|---|---|---|---|
| Picture | 1/5 | 37.18% verified plant evidence | 971/1,116 complete; 39 missing declarations; 106 technical gaps; provisional |
| Gray Label | 3/5 | 85.67% verified plant evidence | 305/394 complete; 0 missing declarations; 89 technical gaps; provisional |
The textile scale is plant-fibre composition, not overall sustainability. The current ordinary bands are 1/5 below 40%, 2/5 from 40%, 3/5 from 60%, 4/5 from 90% and 5/5 only at 100% verified plant evidence. Cotton, linen and hemp count as plant fibre.
Wool and silk are natural but animal-derived, so do not meet this plant-only preference; viscose and modal are not counted as eligible plant fibre in this standard. The method has a disclosed animal-material exception.
We do not boost this score because a garment is popular, a celebrity wears it, its packaging is recycled, or an unrelated brand-policy app likes the company.
Labour conditions, dyes, animal welfare, ownership and lifecycle impact remain important, but must be assessed separately with appropriate evidence. A low textile score must never be presented as proof of wrongdoing. Read the live scoring method.
Explore My Ideal World and sign up for the underlying research, rather than treating another app’s numerical score as our result.
Android and Apple downloads, what is actually public?
Android downloads are published by Google Play as rounded minimum thresholds; Apple does not publicly provide cumulative app downloads. The Apple figures below are marked undisclosed rather than guessed. These figures do not measure monthly active users, product-scanning accuracy or retention. Checked in November 2026.
| App | Android downloads | Apple iPhone downloads | Source or next step |
|---|---|---|---|
| Good On You | 100K+ | Not publicly disclosed | Google Play installation threshold |
| My Ideal World (MIW) | Not publicly disclosed | Not publicly disclosed | Explore the app and sign up |
Google Play figures are lower-bound installation bands. Apple provides actual download statistics to each publisher through App Store Connect, not as a comparable public leaderboard. An App Store rating count is not a download count.
My Ideal World is listed last because it is our app, and no unverified install figures are claimed. Apple developer explanation of download reports.
People, planet and animals are separate tests
Open Good On You’s methodology and explain which disclosed data affects each part. Do not turn a rating into a guarantee for the entire product line.
The second-hand paradox
A used item from a badly rated brand can sometimes be a practical alternative to buying another new item. Discuss lifetime, laundering, repairs and actual need instead of delivering a simplistic moral verdict.
Fibres are a composition question
Polyester, organic cotton, viscose and recycled mixes have different material characteristics. A tag is a starting point; undocumented chemical finishing or dye conditions remain unknown.
Where the comparison can go wrong
An ethical fashion comparison needs the actual garment tag and the brand’s published policy data. A 100% natural-fibre result tells us something about material composition. A labour score tells us something else. Neither one gives permission to invent the missing half of the story.
A brand score won’t tell me what I am wearing
Good On You answers useful questions about people, planet and animals. The fibre tag answers a different one. Keep both. A garment can fail my all natural fibre threshold without making its founder a bad person, and a natural shirt can still leave difficult labour questions unanswered.
Good On You is not trying to scan every shirt
Good On You examines brands’ policies and performance across people, planet and animals. Those dimensions matter, but they are not an independent fibre assay of the specific garment in a shopper’s hand. Before shopping, decide whether you need brand accountability, an exact material composition or a resale listing. A different tool may be more appropriate for each.
The natural-fibre standard is deliberately stricter
A clothing brand can be praised for improving factory practices while selling garments containing polyester, elastane or other synthetics. Under a composition-purity approach a garment made from genuinely 100% natural fibre may meet the top fibre threshold, while a mixture will not.
That does not erase the importance of the brand’s workers or make every natural fibre environmentally optimal. Keep those questions separate.
Repair changes the purchase decision
If a coat you already own only needs a zip, its practical value can outweigh a pristine sustainability badge on a new coat. Check the type of repair, quote the local price, assess garment construction and estimate whether you will actually continue wearing it.
Buying an expensive new ‘eco’ item to replace a functional garment is not automatically a better environmental choice.
The research readers deserve
Name the garment’s declared fibre percentages, relevant certification scope and evidence of suppliers. Do not confuse a corporate report with a worker’s voice.
If independent factory interviews or remediation documents are unavailable, describe that gap plainly. A credible fashion guide should be comfortable saying ‘I can’t verify this part’.
Repair, resale and a new ethical collection cannot be put on one ladder
Suppose a person has a jacket whose zip has failed. A local repair may keep the jacket in use for years. A second-hand replacement may be a good option if repair is impractical.
A newly made coat from a brand with a strong sustainability policy is a different decision again. One broad ranking cannot establish which has the lowest environmental impact without taking account of actual use, travel, materials and what purchase is avoided.
This is why apps serving the same audience can still be complementary. A resale marketplace finds used items; a repair directory finds expertise; Good On You evaluates published brand evidence; MIW looks at composition and related brand research. The best tool follows the problem, not the logo. A useful comparison includes the option to buy nothing.
Factory evidence is the part that should not disappear behind a star
A supplier code of conduct is a promise. An audit is a review of specified conditions at a time and place, often commissioned by someone with a commercial relationship.
A worker interview is a person’s account, with all the context and limitations that entails. None alone represents an entire global supply chain.
When a brand publishes a corrective-action report, read how many cases were found, which were fixed and what evidence exists that the fix lasted.
The reporting should name people when the source supports it, not invent a brave anonymous worker to make a point. If a company has not disclosed its factories, say that. If it has published an extensive supplier map, acknowledge it. A purist material standard should not become an excuse to ignore human labour.
A fashion field test you can repeat
Choose a shirt, trousers and jacket from clearly identified collections. Record exact fibre percentages from their sewn-in labels, not only the online product description.
Check whether an organic or recycled certification covers the fibre, yarn, fabric or finished product. Look for repair instructions, a returns policy and spare buttons or zip parts. Then read the brand’s public sourcing and labour documentation.
If the same brand markets all three as conscious but the materials and evidence differ, let the article show the difference. Keep Good On You’s brand assessment in one column and MIW’s product-purity result in another. A disagreement is expected when the frameworks measure different things. Explain it rather than forcing a consensus.
Further reading and primary sources
- Good On You published method
- Good On You Google Play
- WRAP textiles research
- Independent repair resources
- UNEP textiles
Good On You gives the reader an answer about the company
Its methodology assesses public evidence across people, planet and animals. The publisher says its 2026 system draws on many data points and converts underlying assessments into a five-level rating. The result concerns disclosed company practices, not a physical analysis of every garment made by the brand.
That distinction matters when someone searches for a Good On You alternative. If their problem is finding a specific 100% natural-fibre shirt, a company-level rating may not provide the answer. If the concern is living wages or forced labour, the material tag will not answer it either.
The five-point output hides a more elaborate model
Good On You’s published explanations describe an underlying score out of one hundred and rating bands from We Avoid to Great. A five-out-of-five rating signifies its highest broad brand-performance category, not the same thing as MIW’s top natural-fibre composition threshold.
Both systems can legitimately use five stars while measuring different things. The comparison should say so in the first screen, not bury it after several purchasing recommendations.
Public evidence is a deliberate choice
Good On You states that its analysts use publicly available brand and parent-company reporting. The logic is that consumers should be able to inspect the evidence behind a company’s environmental and labour claims.
That is a useful transparency principle. It also creates a limitation: a company doing worthwhile work without publicly documenting it may receive less credit than a well-disclosing rival.
The answer is not to accept unverifiable private assurances as facts. It is to encourage public documentation and clearly distinguish non-disclosure from demonstrated misconduct.
One garment can contradict the brand’s broad reputation
A fashion company may receive a good rating for its overall policies while one of its garments contains a high proportion of synthetic fibre. That specific item would not satisfy a strict natural-fibre preference.
The brand’s labour and environmental performance cannot change the textile composition written on the tag.
Conversely, a product made entirely of cotton or linen says little about whether the workers were paid fairly. The consumer needs two separate answers rather than a forced average.
The role of chemical processing cannot be inferred from a material label
A shirt may be made from natural fibre and then dyed, finished or treated. The fibre tag identifies composition in one sense, but it does not report every processing chemical or residual substance. A purity-focused guide should disclose that distinction rather than present the words 100% cotton as a complete toxicology report.
A test of actual residues requires suitable sampling and analytical methods. If there is no such test, say the treatment information is unknown. That honest gap is better than a false claim of being entirely chemical-free.
The labour question deserves workers’ voices
Codes of conduct, supplier lists and audits are useful documents. None automatically captures every worker’s experience or the impact of wage arrangements. Where a brand claims leadership on people, ask whether it publishes remediation data, worker representation and specific progress.
A journalist should seek attributable interviews and credible independent investigations rather than inventing a worker’s story. A score is an entry into reporting, not the final substitute for it.
Why a second-hand garment changes the moral calculation
Resale marketplaces help extend the life of existing clothes, but they do not directly assess the original manufacturer’s labour history. That is a distinct value proposition.
Someone may reasonably choose a used item from a poorly rated brand instead of buying new, particularly if it is durable and genuinely needed.
A guide that insists the shopper purchase a newly made garment from the highest-rated brand can miss the practical environmental value of reuse. The honest comparison includes doing nothing, repairing and buying second hand.
What a useful comparison of two jackets would include
Take two actual jackets of similar purpose. Record fabric percentages, repairable construction, expected use, pricing, published company rating and available supplier evidence.
If one is second hand, identify the condition and needed alterations. Do not claim precise lifecycle emissions without a compatible study.
This is the kind of table a reader can use. It is also the moment when an app should link to another question rather than re-score the same product repeatedly.
How much does a garment cost every time you wear it?
Before buying a supposedly ethical fashion item, I would compare what the company can prove with how long I expect to keep it. My Ideal World’s Cost Per Wear and Fibre Checker tools make those questions practical, without mistaking a low cost per wear for proof of fair labour.
Our sustainable fashion app comparison explains why different tools can disagree about the same garment. And if you’re buying less rather than hunting for another label, the habit tracking guide may be the more useful next read.
What I learned from building a harsh composition standard
It is uncomfortable to give a low rating to a clothing brand owned by someone you know. A friend may have built a thoughtful business and still sell a blended-fibre product that does not meet the published purity threshold. The score should not change because of the relationship.
I want the result to be useful to the maker without suggesting the whole business is unethical. If the underlying fibre data is wrong, it must be corrected. If the material is correctly identified, the owner can disagree with the standard without the app misrepresenting them.
The useful alternative is a combination, not always one app
Use a brand-rating service to investigate social and environmental policies, the garment’s physical label to verify fibre, a repair or resale service to consider alternatives, and MIW where its composition and deeper brand research are relevant. The choice of tool should follow the question.
This is not a compromise invented to avoid declaring a winner. It reflects the fact that sustainability encompasses different kinds of information and that an honest product cannot pretend to measure all of them equally.
Use My Ideal World for the next question
Save the exact garment or brand research and compare it with what the marketing claims. Take the evidence you can see, note the gap you cannot, and continue through the relevant brand or product research. Explore My Ideal World and create an account.
Continue the investigation. sustainable fashion apps comparison · how to tell if a brand is really sustainable
On this story
Comments, questions and answers from signed-in paid members. The conversation is shared with the app. Community contributions are not verified editorial findings.
Contribute evidence
Reviews share first-hand experience. Observations can include opinions and objections. Evidence is checked against its sources before publication. Community contributions do not change MIW scores.
Article discussions and evidence contributions are for paid members and are shared with the app.
Sign in to contribute or join the discussion


